Passenger Samier Tadros filed a $15,000 civil lawsuit against MSC Cruises in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Passaic County, following the cancellation of his confirmed transatlantic cruise reservation about 36 to 37 hours before departure.
Cruise Itinerary and Booking Details
Tadros purchased the cruise reservation in Clifton, New Jersey, through CruiseDirect, a travel agency operated by International Voyager, Inc. based in Morristown, New Jersey. The reservation was for the MSC Grandiosa, set to depart Barcelona, Spain, on October 31, 2026, and arrive in Port Canaveral, Florida. The itinerary did not include any ports of call in Italy.
MSC Cruises canceled Tadros’s sailing under its
Code of Conduct approximately two days before the scheduled departure, citing no specific violation despite Tadros’s written requests for clarification. Earlier correspondence from MSC’s executive office acknowledged the upcoming October 31 sailing in September 2026.
Jurisdictional Dispute Over Legal Venue
MSC Cruises’ legal counsel demands that the case be litigated in Naples, Italy, based on a forum-selection clause in its booking conditions. Tadros contests this requirement, arguing that his U.S.-based booking location, Florida arrival port, and lack of Italian itinerary stops make enforcement of the Italian litigation venue inappropriate.
MSC Cruises is headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland, with U.S. offices located in Florida. The plaintiff has
emphasized that the cruise line’s conditions distinguish litigation venues between voyages with and without U.S. ports, and he seeks judicial review of whether those terms apply to his booking.
Plaintiff’s Statements and Impact of Cancellation
Samier Tadros, an experienced cruiser with more than 40 completed cruises, said, “I booked in New Jersey through a New Jersey company for a cruise ending in Florida, and the ship was never scheduled to visit Italy.” He also noted, “Pursuing a $15,000 consumer claim in an overseas court creates substantial financial and logistical barriers for an individual passenger.”
Tadros had incurred out-of-pocket expenses for travel to Europe ahead of the
sailing and stated that the canceled cruise would have qualified him for the Blue Diamond tier of MSC’s Voyagers Club loyalty program. He seeks a U.S. court hearing to gain an explanation for the last-minute cancellation and a practical resolution of the dispute.
Legal Context and Case Details
The lawsuit, docket number PAS-DC-020840-26, is pending in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, Special Civil Part, Passaic County. It challenges the enforceability of international forum-selection clauses in U.S.-booked cruises without Italian ports and addresses issues of passenger contract enforcement and pre-departure cancellation disclosures.
The claims in the complaint remain contested by MSC Cruises, which
retains the right to dispute the substantive allegations, jurisdiction, and contract terms. The lawsuit underscores tensions regarding venue provisions and consumer rights in international cruise bookings.











